Fiscal indiscipline and death of public services in Uganda

Abstract

This paper investigates the causal pathways through which chronic fiscal indiscipline has precipitated the systemic collapse of public
services in Uganda over the period 2000-2023. Combining a synthetic-control fiscal shock analysis with an original service-delivery
scorecard covering 2,400 sub-counties, we estimate that every 1 percentage-point increase in the structural primary deficit is
associated with a 0.78-point deterioration in an aggregate Public Service Performance Index (PSPI). Disaggregated results reveal
that health and water services have contracted most severely (-1.13 and -0.97 PSPI points respectively), while education outcomes
have stagnated despite rising enrolments. Event-study estimates around three major shocks—(i) the 2006 election-cycle spending
surge, (ii) the 2011 oil-boom borrowing spree, and (iii) the 2020 COVID-19 emergency disbursements—show that non-concessional
debt crowds out pro-poor recurrent budgets within four quarters, with effects persisting for at least five years. Qualitative evidence
from 147 key-informant interviews across 18 districts corroborates the quantitative findings: frontline providers report chronic stock-
outs of essential medicines, delayed teacher salaries, and collapsing rural road networks directly linked to arrears accumulation and
off-budget expenditures. Finally, we simulate the counterfactual impact of enforcing a constitutional debt-limit rule coupled with a
medium-term expenditure framework; the results indicate that Uganda could have averted 38 % of the observed decline in service
delivery and reduced extreme-poverty headcount by 4.2 percentage points. The paper concludes with politically feasible institutional
reforms—anchored on transparent oil-revenue earmarking and an independent fiscal council—to break the cycle of fiscal profligacy
and revive equitable public services.

IPRAA WORKING PAPER 164

JEL Code: E24, F13, F14
Key words: ASEAN, employment, international trade, trade policy, revealed
comparative advantage, Asia Pacific, Myanmar

We are a leading independent, nonpartisan research organization dedicated to advancing evidence-based policy solutions for sustainable economic development in Africa.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Stay connected with IPRA’s quarterly newsletter featuring the latest news, book releases, and original content.

Newsletter Form (#4)

Become a Non-Resident Fellow

Copyright © 2025 Institute of Policy Research and Analysis. All rights reserved.